Templates & Tips

Providing you with relevant legal documents and templates.

首页 > Templates & Tips

Shenzhen Inheritance Lawyer: When the Estate Is Very Large and an Heir Refuses to Agree on Appraisal and Valuation, What Can Be Done?

Author: Dao Hua Marriage and Family Law FirmDate: 2026-11-18Reads:times

Keywords: high-value estate appraisal, valuation-based estate division, appraisal disputes in inheritance cases, Shenzhen inheritance lawyer

When the estate is large and its types are complex, deciding on a price is often harder than deciding how to divide it. A house, a company, a collection of artwork—each heir has their own figure in mind: the one who wants the property hopes the valuation is low; the one who wants cash hopes it is high. If they cannot agree, the case stalls at the appraisal stage.

摄图网_500931502_拒绝_(企业商用).jpg

Under the law, division of the estate shall be conducive to production and living needs and shall not impair the utility of the estate; estate that is unsuitable for physical division may be handled through offset valuation, appropriate compensation, or tenancy in common (Article 1156 of the Civil Code). In other words, the court does not require every asset to be cut into shares; it may resolve the matter by letting one party take the asset while the others receive compensation. As to how value is determined, the parties usually negotiate; where negotiation fails, the court appoints a specialized appraisal agency, and the appraisal conclusion serves as the basis for division.


Where one party objects to appraisal, there are three scenarios to address. First, disagreement over the appraisal agency: the parties may jointly select one by agreement, or failing that, the court may draw lots or appoint one. If there is objection to the appraisal method, a written opinion may be submitted with the appraisal report requesting supplementary explanation. Second, non-acceptance of the appraisal conclusion: a reappraisal may be applied for, but specific grounds must be cited—for example, improper selection of comparable cases, or failure to account for mortgage or seizure status; repeated applications without grounds are generally not supported. Third, refusal to cooperate with the appraisal such that progress cannot be made: the court may determine value based on the available evidence, and the party that refuses to appear or provide materials may bear adverse consequences. In addition, if a particular asset cannot be agreed on for a long time, the undisputed portion may be divided first and the disputed property dealt with separately, so the overall case is not held up. In one inheritance case our firm handled involving three properties in Shenzhen and equity in a company, the parties had widely divergent views on the equity valuation. We recommended first dividing the real estate at appraised value through offset compensation and appraising the equity separately; most of the disputes were ultimately resolved in pre-trial mediation.


Recommended preparations in advance: ownership documents for the property, purchase contracts and invoices, market transaction data for comparable assets, the company's financial statements and audit reports, and each party's written views on the appraisal agency and method. In summary, appraisal disagreement is not an impasse: the key is to select the agency, define the method, and preserve recourse against the uncooperative party. We recommend settling the appraisal plan with a lawyer before filing suit.


Online AppointmentMADE AN APPOINTMENT

No registration required, quick appointment, expert lawyers provide customized legal service solutions

  • Consultation Appointment:400-829-6880
  • Private Space:18126123723
  • Law Firm: Guangdong Daohua Law Firm
  • Email:DAOHUALAWMF@163.com
  • Address:810, Rongchao Economic & Trade Center, 4028 Jintian Road, Futian District, Shenzhen (Next to Civic Center)
Appointment WeChat
Team Public Account